Turn Nutter Butters into Uncle Sam Cookies for 4th of July

There back! I’m talking about Nutter Butters. I can’t help myself. They are the ideal canvas on which to create so many edible crafts and their peanut shape was absolutely perfect for these Uncle Sam Cookies.

We are going to a friend’s party on July 4th and the idea to create these patriotic cookies was hers. She knows I love working with Nutter Butters and she has been the lucky recipient of many a chocolate covered peanut butter cookie treat. 
This friend has fun trying to help me brainstorm ideas. Some of her suggestions are a bit wacky, but then, so is she, that’s why I love her. But on more than one occasion she has helped me devise a plan for making something truly great, and although I designed these Uncle Sam Nutter Butters, she gets credit for the idea!
I know many of you will think these look like a lot of work, and you’d be right. But, if you work in an assembly line style, they really don’t take that long to make. I used modeling chocolate to create Uncle Sam’s facial features and his stars and stripes hat. If you cut all the pieces out then do the assembly they come together pretty easily. 
If you still haven’t tried working with modeling chocolate, you really should give it a whirl. It’s soft and pliable and easy to work with, but then it hardens up enough to stay rigid. Plus, it tastes like chocolate. What could be better? 

Uncle Sam Nutter Butter Cookies

You’ll Need:
Nutter Butter Cookies
white confectionery coating/Candy Melts
orange candy coloring
dipping fork or kitchen fork
parchment paper lined baking sheet

cutting board
powdered sugar

red and blue food coloring
1 1/2 inch square cookie cutter
mini star plunger cutter
food use only paint brushes
food use only tweezers
clay extruder with multi hole disc

Before you begin, for detailed instructions of melting and coloring confectionery coating, making and coloring modeling chocolate, see my Chocolate Making Tips page


Melt your white confectionery coating. If you don’t have experience melting candy coating, see my Chocolate Making Tips page for instructions
Color the candy coating with a very small amount of orange candy coloring. You want a skin color. I should have gone just a bit darker on mine. In person the skin color on Uncle Sam’s face looks great, but in pictures it’s a bit too light. 

Dip a your Nutter Butter Cookies in the peach candy coating. Completely cover the cookie, then lift the cookie out of the melted candy coating using a dipping fork or kitchen fork. Tap the fork on the side of the bowl a few times, allowing the excess candy coating to drip off the cookie. Set the dipped cookies on a parchment paper lined baking sheet. 

Dip about 6 cookies, then put them in the freezer for about 5 minutes. If you make an entire tray of these dipped cookies, by the time you freeze them, the first cookies you dipped with have hardened, and will develop white streaks and spots on them. 

Dust your cutting board lightly with powdered sugar. Roll out some red, white, and blue modeling chocolate to about 1/16th of an inch thickness. Cut one square of each color for the hat. Cut the blue square in half. Cut four thin stripes and 1 wide stripe out of the white square. Cut three mini stars out of the remaining piece of white. Cut a hat brim out of red. 
Color some modeling chocolate skin color using a small amount of orange coloring. Pinch off small pieces and roll into balls for the nose. Flatten some smaller balls into discs, then cut off one edge to become ears. 
Insert some white modeling chocolate into a clay extruder fitted with a multi hole plate. Press out the spaghetti like strands of modeling chocolate. Cut off 1/2 inch lengths of the strands. Pinch together both ends creating the moustache, beard, and hair. Reshape as needed.
Cut off 1/4 inch pieces and create curved eyebrows. 

To make Uncle Sam’s hat, brush the bottom of the red square with some water. Press one piece of blue modeling chocolate so that only half of it is on the red square. This will elongate the hat into a rectangle. Brush the backsides of the white stripes with water. Press them onto the red square, creating red and white stripes. Cut off excess. 
Attach the min stars to the blue band using water, then attach the hat brim to the bottom edge of the blue band. 
Use melted confectionery coating to attach the hat to the top half of the dipped Nutter Butter Cookie. Create Uncle Sam’s face, by using the melted candy coating as glue to attach two eyes, eyebrows, a nose, the moustache and beard, ears, and hair. To make the eyebrows look fuzzy, use a knife to cut along the edges of the modeling chocolate. 
If you are making a lot of these cookies, create all the decorative pieces then assemble them all at once, adding the hats first, then adding the facial features, and lastly adding the hair and ears. 

Store these in an airtight container for up to several weeks. Don’t refrigerate them, but be sure to keep them in a cool spot at your 4th of July party.

Thanks for sharing this on Pinterest, Facebook, 
your blog, etc. by using the buttons below. 
Please post one picture, mention
 and link back to Hungry Happenings.

Be sure to send pictures of your
 recipe recreations
to share in the Readers’ Gallery

For a complete list of linky parties I attend, go here
Thank you for visiting Hungry Happenings 

– Beth

Items used to create this project that are available on Amazon.com (commission earned for sales)

Print Friendly
Thanks for sharing!


    • says

      Lisa, I loved your spoons. I was working on this blog post when you're e-mail came in, and I saw Uncle Sam and my first thought was "oh, that is so clever!" Using spoons was a great idea, and the shapes spoons you used were perfect of Uncle Sam.

    • says

      Thanks Sara. I must admit these do have quite a bit of detail to them and will take some time to replicate. I only made three which was enough to make the 4th of July party guests oooh and aaaah:)

  1. Anonymous says

    Beth, I think these are your best yet, but I always feel that way until I see your next project, lol I love this and I have never liked an Uncle Sam picture until now. Thanks Trish utler

    • says

      Yeah, I never liked Uncle Sam too much either. He always seemed so angry. But these guys are pretty sweet looking. I'm glad you like them!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *