Turn store-bought cookies into adorably cute Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter Penguins with Marshmallow Bellies. They are so fun to make using marshmallows, candy eyes, and Tootsie Rolls.
Nutter Butter Cookies can be transformed into so many cute little characters for Christmas and I thought the shape of the peanut butter cookies was the perfect body for a penguin.
Trying to make this project really easy, I made a few penguins where I just frosted the cookies with Nutella and added the marshmallow belly, Tootsie Roll wings, Circus Peanut beak and feet, and candy eyes, but I didn't like how the sides of the cookies showed, so I went ahead and dipped them in dark chocolate. They taste great either way.
If you don't have much experience working with chocolate, read my Chocolate Making Tips page (here) before you begin. You can use melted and tempered pure dark chocolate or just melted dark confectionery coating/candy melts for this project. Each penguin will use about an ounce of chocolate, but you'll need extra so you can have enough in your bowl to dip the last few Nutter Butter Cookies.
Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter Penguins
Ingredients
- Nutter Butter Cookies
- Tootsie Rolls
- marshmallows
- Circus Peanuts OR orange taffy, orange Starburst Fruit Chews, orange Tootsie Rolls
- candy eyes
- melted and tempered dark chocolate OR melted dark confectionery coating/candy melts
Supplies
- kitchen shears or knife
- dipping fork or kitchen fork
- parchment paper lined baking sheet
Items used to create this project are available on Amazon.com. I earn a small commission when you use the Amazon links to make a purchase at no extra cost to you.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter...Shop on Amazon 
¼" White And Black Icing ...Shop on Amazon
Ghirardelli Dark Candy Maki...Shop on Amazon
SweetGourmet Orange Circus ...Shop on AmazonInstructions
Get your decorations ready. Take your Nutter Butter Cookies out of the package. Cut a thin slice from each round end of your marshmallows. (The center slices will be too sticky to use, so just snack on them or save them and dip them in the leftover chocolate.)
Unwrap your Tootsie Rolls and smash them flat. You may need to heat them in the microwave for a few seconds to soften them up.
Use kitchen shears or a knife to cut wings from the Tootsie Rolls. Cut off small pieces of your Circus Peanut or other orange candy, and shape them into triangular beaks and teardrop-shaped feet.
Dip one Nutter Butter Cookie in the melted and tempered dark chocolate or melted confectionery coating. Use a dipping fork or kitchen fork to remove the cookie from the chocolate. Tap the fork on the side of your bowl to allow the excess chocolate to drip off. Set on a parchment paper lined baking sheet. Immediately attach all your candy decorations while the chocolate is still wet.
Place the marshmallow, cut side down, on your chocolate-dipped Nutter Butter. Attach one wing to each side of the cookie and two feet to the bottom of the cookie. Then add the eyes and beak.
Refrigerate if using pure dark chocolate and freeze if using confectionery coating/candy melts for about 5 minutes, just until the coating hardens.
Storage
Store in an airtight container for up to several weeks.
These cute little Nutter Butter Penguins will make great Christmas party favors. Wrap them individually in clear cellophane bags to give as treats. I plan to add mine to cookie trays for our Christmas Open House.
Related Recipes
Here are some more fun penguin-themed recipe ideas.
Be sure to check out all my fun Christmas Recipes!
Recipe
- 6 Nutter Butter Cookies
- 6 Tootsie Rolls
- 3 marshmallows
- 3 Circus Peanuts OR orange taffy orange Starburst Fruit Chews, orange Tootsie Rolls
- 12 candy eyes
- 12 ounces melted and tempered dark chocolate OR melted dark confectionery coating/candy melts
-
Cut a thin slice from each round end of your marshmallows.
-
Unwrap Tootsie Rolls and smash them flat.
-
Use kitchen shears or a knife to cut wings from the Tootsie Rolls.
-
Cut off small pieces of your Circus Peanut or other orange candy, and shape into triangular beaks, and tear drop shaped feet.
-
Dip one Nutter Butter Cookie in the melted and tempered dark chocolate or melted confectionery coating.
-
Set on a parchment paper lined baking sheet.
-
Immediately attach all your candy decorations while the chocolate is still wet.
-
Attach two Tootsie Roll wings, one candy beak, two candy feet, one marshmallow belly, and two candy eyes.
-
Chill in the refrigerator if using pure chocolate and in the freezer if using candy melts for about 5 minutes until the chocolate hardens.
- Gingerbread Cookie Cups - December 2, 2023
- Cheeseburger Skulls - October 15, 2023
- Mini Peanut Butter Cheesecakes - June 20, 2023
farmlife chick
Sooo cute!
Trish - Mom On Timeout
Beth, seriously, these are SO cute! Pinned! Thanks so much for sharing at Mom On Timeout!
Crystelle Boutique
These are super cute and so yummy looking. My daughter loves them!
hugs x
Crystelle
Millie Snyder
This looks like a great craft for kids! My grand-kids would love to make them!
Nicole Smith
Awesome! I love the tootsie roll arms! And I love how you show how each piece of the penguin was cut out. Makes it really easy to follow along!
Brenda
Penguins can't get any cuter 🙂
Lori WhoNeedsaCape
Awww, my kids would love these!
Anonymous
You must be very popular where I live as I can't find one nutter-butter cookie anywhere. I just love these guys. Trish Butler (Motheroverkill)
Michelle | Creative Food
These are so cute!!! I love your penguins! I only wish Nutter Butters were also made Peanut Free! I always see the cutest creations made with them!
Sue
Leave it to you to create another cute cookie with the Nutter Butters:) Love them, Beth!
Lisa
ok i LOVE these! 🙂
The Partiologist
Another super cute design out of store bought cookies - and the perfect combination of chocolate a peanut butter!! YUM
DesignedByBH
Oh, these are beyond cute! Thanks for sharing!
CuteEverything.com
So adorable, I love how these turned out and the Nutter Butters are the Perfect shape!
Amy CookingAdventures
Oh my gosh - I LOVE these! Plus they're sot Christmasy, so I can totally make them in January! Yay!
Tiffany@Fizzy Party!
These are adorable!
Beth (www.livinglifeintentionally.blogspot.com)
These are SUPER DUPER cute!! You come up with the coolest creations!
Beth =-)
Tiffany Yang
Awwww..... so cute!
Patricia Reitz
Oh my goodness, sooooo cute!!!
Katrina Bahl
I love these little guys!!