If you want some fun Sesame Street party treats you’ve got to make these adorable Cookie Monster Pretzels. Each mini pretzel twist coated in blue candy melts and sprinkles has big, googly, candy eyes and a big mouth stuffed with a chocolate chip cookie.
Cookie Monster Pretzels
Like most kids in America I grew up watching Sesame Street and the character I related to the most was the furry blue Cookie Monster. He couldn’t get enough cookies and was so elated every time he ate one. Yep, he was my kindred spirit. I’m sure many of you can relate.
All of the Muppets are so incredibly cute, but there’s something so sweet about the furry, blue, cookie-eating monster. The simple shape of Jim Henson’s puppets make them easy to recreate as food crafts.
When I came up with the idea of turning some Sesame Street characters into pretzels I just had to start with Cookie Monster. He has big googly eyes and a mouth that’s almost always stuffed with cookies.
These cute Cookie Monster Pretzels are super easy to make and will be so much fun to serve to the kids at your Sesame Street themed party.
Then you’ll sprinkle on lots of blue jimmies (sprinkles). The blue jimmies not only make the candy dipped pretzels look furry but they also fill in the holes.
Add 1/2 inch candy eyes and a Mini Oreo Cookie mouth and you have Cookie Monster.
Stuff a cookie in his mouth to make him look even cuter. You’ll need tiny chocolate chip cookies. Cookie Crisp cereal works great.
Cut about 1/3rd off of each cookie so that you can attach them to Cookie Monster’s mouth using some of the blue candy melts.
If you can’t find chocolate chip cookie cereal, you could always make tiny homemade cookies or create them out of modeling chocolate.
Watch this video tutorial to see how you can quickly and easily make a bunch of these Cookie Monster Pretzels for your Sesame Street party.
You can find the supplies to make these Cookie Monster Pretzels on amazon (commission earned for sales).
Use a sharp knife to cut each chocolate cookie into two half moon shaped mouths.
Cut about 1/3rd off of each chocolate chip cookie cereal.
Discard or snack on the smaller 1/3rd.
Set the larger pieces aside.
Dip one mini pretzel twist in blue candy melts using a dipping tool or fork.
Remove and allow excess candy to drip off.
Set on a parchment paper lined baking sheet.
Immediately attach one cookie mouth at the bottom edge of the pretzel twist.
Sprinkle blue jimmies over top and allow to dry for 10 minutes.
Repeat coating all 36 of your pretzels.
After the pretzels have dried pick them up and allow the excess sprinkles to fall off.
Use blue candy melts to attach two candy eyes along the top edge of the pretzel.
Brush blue candy melts along the cut edge of a chocolate chip cookie cereal and immediately attach it to Cookie Monster's mouth.
Repeat.
Have fun making these Cookie Monster Pretzels. If you make them and share them online be sure to link back to this blog post, mention Hungry Happenings, and use #hungryhappenings.
See the video tutorial for making Elmo Pretzels too…
Sesame Street came after my time, but EVERYONE knows and loves him now no matter their age. Thanks for the size of the eyes and other tips so we get it right the very first time. Your detail is much appreciated.
Bet YOUR Cookie Monster brought a lot of customers into your shop. Who could resist? 🙂
Someone asked me to make one of the newer characters from the show and I had no idea who she was talking about. I’m a bit out of touch, but the Muppets I grew up with and even Elmo will always have a place in my heart. The Cookie Monster costume really worked wonders. Everyone was excited to see the furry blue monster at my store.
I hadn’t thought about it until reading your comment just how much Cookie Monster has been a part of my life. I actually owned a Cookie Monster costume that I used for my first retail store. I sold cookies and chocolates and I’d hire people to wear the costume for events and to pass out flyers or wave at customers driving by. I still have a few Cookie Monster t-shirts. He’s definitely been a big part of my life too!
I have loved Elmo and Cookie Monster for years and years, and these treats are so cute, makes me want to have a sesame street party!
I know that if you hosted a Sesame Street Party it would be spectacular.
Sesame Street came after my time, but EVERYONE knows and loves him now no matter their age. Thanks for the size of the eyes and other tips so we get it right the very first time. Your detail is much appreciated.
Bet YOUR Cookie Monster brought a lot of customers into your shop. Who could resist? 🙂
Tavette – S. Fla.
Someone asked me to make one of the newer characters from the show and I had no idea who she was talking about. I’m a bit out of touch, but the Muppets I grew up with and even Elmo will always have a place in my heart. The Cookie Monster costume really worked wonders. Everyone was excited to see the furry blue monster at my store.
I love Cookie Monster too! Sesame Street was such a big part of my childhood as well and you’ve perfectly captured the silly blue monster! 🙂
I hadn’t thought about it until reading your comment just how much Cookie Monster has been a part of my life. I actually owned a Cookie Monster costume that I used for my first retail store. I sold cookies and chocolates and I’d hire people to wear the costume for events and to pass out flyers or wave at customers driving by. I still have a few Cookie Monster t-shirts. He’s definitely been a big part of my life too!
These are adorable. Of course, I’m a sucker for anything cookie monster…
Thanks! I am a sucker too. 🙂