Thanksgiving Pilgrim Suit Cupcakes with Chocolate Cupcake Wrappers

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Suit Cupcakes |


Making edible chocolate cupcake wrappers has become a bit of an obsession for me this week. I began with one simple Christmas wrapper idea, then couldn’t stop and ended up making an entire series of festive holiday designs. I figured while I was playing in the kitchen, I’d come up with at least one for Thanksgiving.I don’t recall ever eating a cupcake at Thanksgiving dinner. Have you? Are they a popular dessert for this holiday? I’m not sure, but, I couldn’t resist making a pilgrim suit cupcake wrapper, anyway.

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Suit Cupcakes |


I thought starting out the holiday series with a simple design was a great idea. Each cupcake wrapper is made using modeling chocolate. Have you made modeling chocolate yet? If not, the time is now. It takes two ingredients, chocolate and corn syrup. It has a similar texture of fondant, is as easy to work with, but tastes so much better. I can’t imagine eating a cupcake wrapped in fondant, but would gladly gobble up cupcakes wrapped in milk, dark, or white modeling chocolate, and this week, I sure have.

Thanksgiving dessert ideas
If you don’t want to make your own modeling chocolate, you can buy ready made tubs from Choco-Pan. It comes in dark and white. You can color the white using coloring or you can even mix the two to get a nice light brown for these wrappers.
Cute Thanksgiving recipes

Edible Cupcake Wrapper – Milk Chocolate Pilgrim Suit

You’ll Need:

modeling chocolate* (recipe can be found on my Chocolate Making Tips page)
non-stick baking mat (or use a gallon size zip top bag)
large fondant rolling pin or wooden rolling pin
pastry wheel, pizza wheel, or knife

*For this project I used milk modeling chocolate for the wrapper, dark modeling chocolate for the band, and peanut butter modeling chocolate (made using Wilton Peanut Butter Candy Melts) for the buckle. If you don’t want to make all three, just use milk chocolate and color some black for the band and add some yellow to make the buckle. You could also add gold luster dust to the buckle. You can see how I used that technique to make my Chocolate Pilgrim Hat Cups, here.
It’s hard to tell you how much modeling chocolate you will need. It will depend on the thickness of each wrapper and the size of your cupcakes. I used about 1.5 ounces for each wrapper, plus the decorations. So estimating 2 ounces per wrapper would be a good idea.

Go here to get a copy of a cupcake wrapper template. Cut out around the template. Wrap it around one of your cupcakes, to see if it is the right size. You need the template to overlap at the ends by at least 1/2 inch, so adjust the template as needed. Re-size then cut out a new template. My cupcakes were big, so I had to enlarge the template. If you are planning to make a lot of cupcakes, you can either print out several templates, or laminate one.
Cupcake wrappers
The best way to roll out modeling chocolate is to pat it into a large round disc, place it on a non-stick baking mat, use a fondant rolling pin to roll it out to about 1/8th inch thickness. If you have two mats, you can use one on top of the modeling chocolate too.
See instructions for rolling out modeling chocolate using a large zip top bag, here.Set the template on the modeling chocolate and use a pastry or pizza wheel to cut out around it. You can use a knife, just be very careful to not cut into your mat.

Cute Thanksgiving recipes
Roll out some black or dark modeling chocolate, use the cupcake wrapper template as a guide to cut out curved strips for the belt. Roll out some peanut butter or light tan or yellow modeling chocolate. Cut out belt buckles. I cut out a small square, using a metal cutter, then cut out around it using a knife.
Attach the belt and buckle to the modeling chocolate cupcake wrapper using water. Just brush a very light coating of water on the back side of the decorations then press them down on the chocolate wrapper to adhere.
Chocolate cupcake recipe
Wrap the decorated wrapper around your cupcake sealing the seams with some water. Frost cupcakes. (Picture was taken for another project, thus the lack of decorations.)


Thanksgiving dessert ideas


I suggest wrapping your cupcakes the day you will use them. You can make the cupcake wrappers ahead of time and store them in an airtight container to keep the flexible. Modeling chocolate hardens a bit as it dries and will have the consistency of a Tootsie Roll. It will hold it’s shape well, but still be soft enough to easily bite into. Keeping the cupcake wrappers stored in Tupperware or Rubbermaid containers will help to keep the modeling chocolate soft and flexible.Do NOT refrigerate.

These cupcakes are meant to be eaten using a fork, and the entire thing is edible.
Thanksgiving dessert recipes

Thanks for sharing this on Pinterest, Facebook, 
your blog, etc. by using the buttons below. 

Please post one picture, mention
 and link back to Hungry Happenings.
Be sure to send pictures of your
 recipe recreations
to share in the Readers’ Gallery
For a complete list of linky parties I attend, go here

Thank you for visiting Hungry Happenings 
– Beth

Items used to create this project that are available on (commission earned for sales)

More Edible Cupcake Wrappers
and Modeling Chocolate Projects
from Hungry Happenings
Easter dessert ideas
Sea themed dessert
Holiday dessert recipes
Twelve Days of Sweet Designs
Polar Bear Rice Krispies Treat
Reindeer Lollipops
Santa Claus Cookie Pops
Elves Caramel pops
Snowmen Marshmallows
Toy Soldier Peanut Butter Fudge Lollipops
Mrs. Claus Chocolate Truffle Pops
Christmas Carolers Candy Bars
Christmas Ornaments Coconut Bars
Christmas Lights Pastry Pockets
Cute Penguin desserts
Print Friendly
Thanks for sharing!


  1. says

    This is beyond adorable Beth! I cannot wait to see all of the other festive designs you come up with, as I am sure they are great!! And I think I will now have to try making one of these myself!!! As who could resist not eating and edible wrapper!!

    • says

      Thanks, Morgan. I can't wait to re-create your Rudolph wrapper. I have four Christmas designs done and have a few more ideas. I can't wait to share them!

    • says

      Thank you, Kakaru. Sorry, I don't sell them. I just make them to share here on my blog. I do sell chocolates, but being my candy kitchen is currently in my home, I can only sell in Ohio.

    • says

      I highly recommend trying modeling chocolate. I love it and know you will too! I can only imagine the designs you will create with your artistic ability:)

  2. says

    Wow what a great thanksgiving treat! I'd love for you to share this tutorial with our Life iterated link party! This week's party is now live :)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *