Sweet Treat for Winter – Nutter Butter Polar Bear Cookies


Once again, a simple peanut shaped Nutter Butter Cookie has found it’s way onto my blog. Every time I look at a Nutter Butter, I can’t help but envision it as an edible craft – and then I eat it. A few cookies do actually survive to become penguins, skulls, puppies, fuzzy pink slippers, or in this case, polar bears.
Nutter Butter Polar BearsBefore you begin, read my Chocolate Making Tips page if you don’t have experience melting and working with candy coating or chocolate.

You’ll need:
2 mini marshmallows per polar bear
melted white confectionery coating/candy melts or melted and tempered pure white chocolate
Nutter Butter Cookies
2 mini chocolate chips per polar bear
1 large chocolate chip per polar bear*
black food coloring marker
*You need a chip that is about 1/2 inch in diameter, which is larger than a standard size chip.
I used Kroger’s Private Selection Brand Semi Sweet Chips,
but Callebaut Chocolate Callets are also the perfect size.
kitchen shears (scissors) or a knife
candy dipping fork or kitchen fork
parchment paper cut into small squares set on a plate or baking sheet
Flatten two mini marshmallows into a circle. Use kitchen shears or a knife to cut off a small piece from one edge so that you can attach the marshmallows to your Nutter Butter.
Dip the cut end of the marshmallow into the melted white confectionery coating.
Press one on each side of the top half of a Nutter Butter Cookie to create the polar bear’s ears.
Allow the candy coating to dry.
Dip the Nutter Butter Cookie into the melted white candy coating, completely submerging it. Use a dipping fork or a kitchen fork to lift the Nutter Butter up out of the white confectionery coating. Allow excess coating to drip off.
Set the dipped cookie on parchment paper.
Immediately while the coating is still wet, press two mini chocolate chips on the cookie for the eyes and one large chocolate chip for the nose.
Freeze for 5 minutes until the candy coating is set. If using pure white chocolate refrigerate instead.
Allow cookie to come to room temperature, then use a food coloring marker to draw on a mouth and eye brows.
Tips:  If you are dipping your Nutter Butter Cookies into white confectionery coating, in order to get nice shiny looking polar bears you’ll want to dip one, decorate it, then place it in the freezer. If you leave your dipped cookies out at room temperature for too long they will develop streaks and spots. If you use small squares of parchment paper set on plates or baking sheets you can easily put your cookies in the freezer as you finish decorating each one.
Store your Nutter Butter Polar Bears in an airtight container for up to several weeks. Do not store in the refrigerator or freezer.
Thanks for sharing this on Pinterest, Facebook, 
your blog, etc. by using the buttons below. 
Please post one picture, mention
 and link back to Hungry Happenings.
Be sure to send pictures of your
 recipe recreations
to share in the Readers’ Gallery
For a complete list of linky parties I attend, go here
Thank you for visiting Hungry Happenings 
– Beth

Items used to create this project that are available on Amazon.com (commission earned for sales)

Print Friendly
Thanks for sharing!


  1. says

    You've done it again, Beth! Your polar bears are perfectly darling! I need to have a closer look at those Nutter Butters and come up with something:)

  2. Anonymous says

    So Cute and delicious too! I just have to try to keep people out of the cookies so I can create before they gobble them up! Nutter Butters are a favorite at our house. Thank You for the instruction Beth, these will be FUN to make :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *